What Montanans Are Reading: “Sheehy’s Plan Hurts Rural Hospitals”

September 18, 2024

Former CFO of hospitals in Whitefish, Dillon, and Miles City speaks out about how Sheehy’s dangerous plan to privatize health care would shutter rural hospitals

Helena, MT – The former CFO of hospitals in Whitefish, Dillon, and Miles City, Jim Alderson, penned an op-ed calling out Tim Sheehy for his dangerous plan to privatize health care. 

The op-ed ran in local papers across the state and highlighted how under Sheehy’s plan for fully privatized health care, rural hospitals would lose tax exemption status, hospital foundations would disappear, non-profitable medical procedures would stop, and hospitals would close. 

Jim is also a retired CPA and the former president of the Montana chapter of the Healthcare Financial Management Association. 

Read more from Jim below. 

Clark Fork Valley Press - Mineral Independent: Sheehy’s plan hurts rural hospitals
By Jim Alderson
September 18, 2024

  • I am a retired CPA and former CFO of hospitals in Whitefish, Dillon and Miles City. In addition I am a past president of the Montana chapter of the Healthcare Financial Management Association.
     

  • Tim Sheehy’s plan to privatize hospitals in Montana will have draconian effects. Local hospitals will no longer have a 501 (c) (3) tax exemption. Thus hospitals will be forced to pay property taxes on land, buildings and equipment. And hospital foundations will go away, as contributions will not be deductible.
     

  • Under private ownership, the hospital will have to pay a handsome return on investment. Of course, unprofitable services will be most likely discontinued. And certainly, many hospitals would close.
     

  • But Montana citizens should not just take my word for it. Call your local hospital board members and administrators and request them to calculate the effect on the hospital if the tax exemption goes away and Medicare and Medicaid cease to exist.
     

  • Montanans love their not-for-profit hospitals. It would be a travesty if Tim Sheehy gets his way and they all get taken over by Wall Street firms.

Latest News

MDP Slams Gianforte's Department of Health and Human Services for Attacking Montanans' Access to Medicaid

July 18, 2025
Gianforte’s Department of Health and Human Services hopes to rush federal changes to the Medicaid Expansion program, forcing Montanans to pay higher costs and jump through additional hoops to… Read More

New Report: Montana Slides to 48th in the Country for Top States for Business Under Gianforte's Watch

July 11, 2025
Helena, MT - CNBC is reporting this week that Montana ranks near the bottom in its annual report of top states to do business, evaluating categories ranging from the economy, infrastructure,… Read More

ICYMI: Big Beautiful Bill Will Have Devastating Impacts on Indigenous Communities in Montana

July 9, 2025
Helena, MT – Lee Newspapers is reporting today that indigenous communities in Montana will be negatively affected by the Trump-inspired, billionaire-first Big Beautiful Bill Act, thanks to the… Read More

Column: The Billionaire's Dream Bill

July 8, 2025
Helena, MT - A new column by the Montana Democratic Party’s Interim Executive Director, Justin Ailport, outlines how Senator Daines and Senator Sheehy (as well as Congressman Zinke and… Read More

MDP Statement on the Passage of Trump's Devastating Budget Bill

July 3, 2025
Helena, MT - In response to the passage of Trump and the GOP’s disastrous budget bill, Montana Democratic Party Interim Executive Director Justin Ailport released the following… Read More